Jell-O Creamsicle Pie is my go to move when I need a dessert that feels like sunshine but I do not want to turn on the oven. You know those days when you promised to bring something sweet, but you also promised yourself you would not stress about it? This is for that exact moment. It tastes like an orange and vanilla ice cream swirl, but in a cold, creamy slice you can actually serve at a table. I started making it for summer hangouts, and now my family asks for it year round. If you like bright citrus desserts that are simple and reliable, you are going to love this one.
The Story Behind This Recipe
I’m Cuts Food, the cook behind this Jell-O Creamsicle Pie. After a few test runs, I dialed in the flavors so it’s easy and full of real-home vibes. Jell-O Creamsicle Pie is my go to move when I need a dessert that feels like sunshine but I do not want to turn on the…
How to Make No Bake Orange Creamsicle Pie
This is a no bake situation, which means it is mostly about mixing and waiting. The flavor is classic: orange, creamy, and a little nostalgic. The trick is using Jell-O for that light set, plus whipped topping for that fluffy bite.
What you will need
- Graham cracker crust (store bought or homemade)
- 1 small box orange Jell-O
- 1 cup boiling water
- 1 cup cold water (or cold orange juice for extra flavor)
- 1 small box vanilla instant pudding mix
- 1 cup cold milk
- 1 tub whipped topping (like Cool Whip), thawed
- Optional: 1 to 2 teaspoons orange zest
My simple step by step
1) In a medium bowl, stir the orange Jell-O into the boiling water until it is totally dissolved. Give it a good 1 minute stir. No gritty bits.
2) Stir in the cold water (or cold orange juice). Then let it sit for about 10 minutes so it is cool, not warm. If it is warm, it can melt the whipped topping and you will lose that airy texture.
3) In another bowl, whisk the vanilla pudding mix with the cold milk until it thickens, about 2 minutes. It will look like a soft pudding.
4) Whisk the cooled orange Jell-O mixture into the pudding. It will loosen up a little, that is normal.
5) Fold in the whipped topping gently. I use a spatula and do big slow turns until it is an even pale orange color. If you want it to taste extra fresh, fold in a little orange zest too.
6) Pour the filling into the graham cracker crust and smooth the top. Then chill it until firm.
If you are in a cozy comfort food mood too, you should peek at this comforting cheesy chicken pot pie with biscuit topping. Totally different vibe than pie for dessert, but it is the kind of dinner that makes dessert feel even more fun.
;
Variations of Creamsicle Pie
Once you make Jell-O Creamsicle Pie the classic way, it is hard not to start playing with it. I have tried a few tweaks over time depending on what I had in the pantry or what the crowd liked.
Here are the variations that actually work, not the ones that look cute online but fall flat.
Crust swaps: A graham cracker crust is the usual, but you can also use a vanilla wafer crust for more of that creamy vanilla vibe. Even an Oreo crust is surprisingly good if you like the chocolate and orange combo.
Make it more orange: Use cold orange juice instead of cold water when you cool the Jell-O. It gives you a brighter flavor and it smells amazing when you mix it.
Make it extra creamy: Mix in 4 ounces of softened cream cheese when you are blending the pudding step. It makes the filling thicker and a little tangy, which I personally love.
Swap the pudding: Vanilla is classic, but cheesecake pudding is incredible here. It leans more like a creamsicle cheesecake without the work.
Mini pies: Spoon the mixture into little cups or mini graham crusts. They set faster and feel party ready.
Whenever I am on an easy dessert kick, I also keep this one bookmarked: creamy Florida lemon pie. It is another cool and citrusy option for when you want something bright but not fussy.
Chilling Time for Best Results
I know chilling sounds like the boring part, but it is honestly where the magic happens. If you cut too early, the slices will slump and look messy. Still tasty, just not as clean.
For Jell-O Creamsicle Pie, I aim for a minimum of 4 hours in the fridge. Overnight is even better if you want that perfect slice. If your fridge is packed or you just opened the door a million times, it can take longer to fully set.
Here are my real life tips:
Cool the Jell-O before you fold it in. If it is even a little warm, it can make the filling loose.
Use the coldest shelf. My bottom shelf sets pies the best.
Do not rush it in the freezer. You can do 30 to 45 minutes in the freezer to speed up the first chill, but do not freeze the whole thing solid or the texture gets weird and icy.
“I made this for a family BBQ and everyone thought it was from a bakery. The orange flavor was spot on and it sliced so nicely after chilling overnight.” Danielle R.
If you are planning a full comfort meal night, I love pairing simple desserts with easy dinners like these cornbread chili pot pies. Warm dinner, cold creamy pie, everybody wins.
How to Store Creamsicle Pie
This is one of those desserts that stores like a dream, which is great because it means you can make it ahead and still feel calm when guests show up.
For the fridge, cover the pie well. I usually press plastic wrap lightly over the top, then cover with foil. If you just tent it with foil, the top can dry out a bit.
Storage basics:
Refrigerator: Keeps well for about 4 days. The crust softens a little over time, but it is still delicious.
Freezer: You can freeze it, but I recommend freezing individual slices. Wrap slices tightly and store in a freezer bag. Let a slice sit in the fridge for a few hours before eating. It becomes kind of like an ice cream pie.
Transporting: Put it in a cooler with ice packs. This pie does not love a hot car ride.
One more thing I learned the hard way: do not store it uncovered near onions or garlicky leftovers. Creamy pies pick up fridge smells faster than you would think.
Popular Garnishes and Serving Suggestions
This pie is already fun on its own, but toppings make it feel extra special with basically no extra effort. If I am bringing it to a party, I garnish it right before serving so everything looks fresh.
- Whipped topping swirls around the edge
- Orange zest sprinkled lightly on top
- Mandarin orange slices, patted dry so they do not weep
- Crushed vanilla wafers for a little crunch
- White chocolate shavings if you want it fancy
Serving tip: run a knife under hot water, wipe it dry, then slice. It makes those clean bakery style cuts.
And if you are building a dessert table, add something chocolatey next to this citrus pie for contrast. These are always a hit: decadent chocolate rice krispie balls everyone will love.
Common Questions
Can I make Jell-O Creamsicle Pie without whipped topping?
Yes, but the texture changes. You can use homemade whipped cream, but stabilize it a bit (like with a spoon of pudding mix or powdered sugar) so it does not deflate.
Why did my pie not set?
Usually the Jell-O was too warm when mixed in, or it did not chill long enough. Give it a full 4 hours, and make sure your fridge is actually cold.
Can I use sugar free Jell-O?
Yep. Sugar free orange Jell-O works fine. The flavor is slightly different, but still good.
Can I make it in a different crust?
Absolutely. Graham cracker is classic, but vanilla wafers or even a shortbread crust taste great. Just make sure it is a crust that holds together when sliced.
How do I keep the crust from getting soggy?
A store bought crust tends to hold up well. If you make your own, you can bake it for 8 to 10 minutes and cool it completely, even though the filling is no bake. That little step helps a lot.
A sweet little plan for your next get together
If you want a dessert that tastes like childhood and takes almost no effort, Jell-O Creamsicle Pie is it. Mix it, chill it, top it, and suddenly you look like the person who always brings the good stuff. I also like keeping other no bake ideas in my back pocket, like this Easy Orange Creamsicle Pie – Meatloaf and Melodrama and this Orange Jello Creamsicle Pie – Smart School House when I want to compare little tweaks. If you give this one a try, chill it long enough and do not skip the zest if you love bold orange flavor. Let me know how you garnish yours, because I am always looking for a new excuse to make Jell-O Creamsicle Pie again.
Jell-O Creamsicle Pie
Ingredients
Method
- In a medium bowl, stir the orange Jell-O into the boiling water until it is totally dissolved, about 1 minute.
- Stir in the cold water or cold orange juice and let it sit for about 10 minutes to cool.
- In another bowl, whisk the vanilla pudding mix with the cold milk until it thickens, about 2 minutes.
- Whisk the cooled orange Jell-O mixture into the pudding until combined.
- Fold in the whipped topping gently until the mixture is evenly pale orange.
- Pour the filling into the graham cracker crust and smooth the top.
- Chill the pie in the fridge for at least 4 hours, preferably overnight, until firm.
